11 Visuals and Tables

Learning Objectives

  • Analyze the rhetorical situation to select the most effective visual format (tables, graphs, charts, or diagrams) for displaying complex or dense data.
  • Evaluate tables for structural integrity, logical organization, precise labeling, and clear mathematical and visual alignment.
  • Audit graphics and figures for data integrity, ethical representation, clarity, and adherence to accessibility standards (such as alt text and color contrast).
  • Apply the principle of visual integration by ensuring all visual elements are properly referenced, captioned, and placed within the text.
  • Collaborate effectively with authors, subject matter experts (SMEs), and graphic designers to resolve visual inconsistencies and formatting errors.

Visuals as Rhetorical and Functional Tools

In professional and technical communication, visuals are not decorative accents added to break up blocks of text. They are essential, functional components of a document’s visual architecture, designed to convey complex, quantitative, or structural information efficiently. Readers of functional nonfiction rarely read linearly from start to finish; instead, they scan documents, jump between section headers, and rely on graphic elements to quickly extract data, understand relationships, or perform critical tasks.

As an editor, your role extends beyond reviewing prose and sentence mechanics; you serve as a visual advocate for the reader. When graphics or tables are poorly formatted, improperly labeled, or disconnected from the surrounding text, they increase cognitive load, introduce confusion, and can lead to dangerous user errors or misinterpretations. Editing visuals and tables requires a balance of high-level substantive evaluation, meticulous mechanical proofreading, and a strong commitment to accessibility and data ethics.

Selecting the Right Visual Representation

One of the first tasks in substantive visual editing is evaluating whether the author selected the correct medium for their information. Authors often present data in prose that would be far clearer in a table, or they create complex, cluttered charts when a simple summary table or list would suffice.

Tables vs. Figures

Visual aids generally fall into two categories: tables and figures.

  • Tables: Systematic arrangements of numbers or text in rows and columns. Tables are best when readers need to look up exact numerical values, compare specific metrics across multiple categories, or review structured textual data (such as feature comparisons or glossaries).
  • Figures: Any visual illustration that is not a table. Figures include line graphs, bar charts, pie charts, flowcharts, organizational diagrams, technical illustrations, photographs, and screenshots. Figures are best when the goal is to show trends over time, display spatial or structural relationships, illustrate processes, or emphasize relative proportions.

Choosing the Effective Graphic Type

When evaluating a figure, assess whether the graphic type aligns with the author’s rhetorical intent:

  • Line Graphs: Ideal for displaying continuous data and illustrating trends or changes over time (e.g., quarterly revenue growth over five years).
  • Bar Charts: Effective for comparing discrete categories or distinct groups (e.g., sales performance across four regional offices).
  • Pie Charts: Best for showing parts of a whole (percentages that sum to 100%). Editorial Note: Pie charts become difficult to read when they contain more than five to seven slices or when slice sizes are nearly identical. In such cases, suggest converting the graphic to a horizontal bar chart or table.
  • Flowcharts and Diagrams: Essential for mapping sequential processes, decision trees, or system architectures.
  • Illustrations and Photographs: Used to show exact physical appearances, spatial layouts, or real-world procedures (e.g., safety equipment assembly).

Editing Tables: Anatomy and Mechanics

Tables aggregate large amounts of information into a compact space, but an improperly formatted table can overwhelm the reader. Editors must ensure that every table is structurally sound, readable, and consistent with the project’s designated style guide (such as APA, Chicago, or an internal house style).

Anatomy of a Table

A well-structured table consists of several key functional components:

  • Table Number and Title: Positioned above the table. The title should be concise, descriptive, and clearly state what the table contains without repeating information in the surrounding text.
  • Column Headers: Clearly identify the data below them. Headers should include units of measurement (e.g., Weight (kg), Revenue (in $ USD), or Frequency (%)) so individual data cells do not need redundant symbols.
  • Stub Column: The leftmost column, which identifies the horizontal categories or item names for each row.
  • Data Cells: The individual intersections of rows and columns containing numbers, text, or symbols.
  • Table Notes/Footnotes: Placed directly below the table frame to define abbreviations, explain missing data, or attribute the data source.

Numerical and Text Alignment Guidelines

Inconsistent alignment within tables is one of the most common design flaws. Editors should apply these standard alignment rules:

  • Numeric Data: Right-align or decimal-align numerical data. Alignment along the decimal point allows readers to compare values quickly by visual inspection.
  • Text Data: Left-align general text cells to maintain a uniform vertical reading edge.
  • Column Headers: Match the alignment of the data below them (i.e., right-align headers over numeric columns, left-align headers over text columns, and center short, single-symbol headers).
  • Empty Cells: Avoid leaving blank data cells, which cause readers to wonder whether data is missing or accidentally omitted. Use standard indicators such as N/A (Not Applicable), ND (No Data), or a dash (—), and explain the notation in a table footnote.

Editing Figures: Clarity, Data Integrity, and Ethics

Editing graphics involves verifying both technical accuracy and visual clarity. While text edits focus on grammar and tone, visual edits ensure that data is presented accurately and without distortion.

Data Integrity and Ethical Representation

Visuals hold significant persuasive power, and poorly designed graphics can unintentionally mislead readers. Editors must audit charts and graphs for common visual distortions:

  • Truncated Baselines: Ensure vertical axes (Y-axes) on bar charts start at zero. Truncating the Y-axis exaggerates small differences between bars, creating a misleading visual impression.
  • Inconsistent Scales: Verify that time intervals on horizontal axes (X-axes) or numerical intervals on vertical axes are evenly spaced.
  • 3D Chart Distortions: Discourage 3D bar or pie charts. Three-dimensional perspectives distort slice proportions and make accurate visual comparison difficult for the reader.
  • Selective Data Cherry-Picking: Check that line charts or trend graphs cover an appropriate, unbiased timeframe rather than selectively highlighting an anomaly to make a biased claim.

Visual Simplicity and Eliminating “Chartjunk”

Coined by data visualization expert Edward Tufte[1], “chartjunk” refers to unnecessary visual elements that distract from the underlying data. Editors should strip away excess clutter:

  • Remove heavy background gridlines or replace them with faint, light-gray lines.
  • Eliminate redundant legends when direct labeling on line graphs or bar charts is clearer.
  • Remove decorative, gradient fills, shadow effects, and unnecessary artificial colors.

Integration, Captions, and Accessibility

A visual element should never exist as an isolated island on a page. To function effectively, visuals must be integrated seamlessly into the text, both rhetorically and structurally.

The Rule of In-Text Integration

Always enforce the Rule of Integration:

  • In-Text Reference: Every table and figure must be explicitly introduced and referenced in the surrounding body text before it appears on the page (e.g., “As shown in Table 11.1, quarterly production increased…”). Never assume the reader will understand why a graphic is included without contextual commentary.
  • Sequential Numbering: Tables and figures must be numbered sequentially in separate series (e.g., Table 11.1, Table 11.2, Figure 11.1, Figure 11.2).
  • Proximity and Placement: Place the visual element immediately following the paragraph in which it is first cited, or at the top of the next page if space constraints dictate. Avoid placing visuals prior to their text introduction.

Captioning Guidelines

Captions serve as an entry point for readers who scan a document before reading the text. An effective caption does more than state a label; it provides context.

Use descriptive titles for simple identifiers (e.g., Figure 11.1: Thermal Efficiency Ratings across System Models). Use informative captions when the graphic requires immediate interpretive context for the reader (e.g., Figure 11.1: System Model C achieved 18% higher thermal efficiency than previous generations under high-load testing).

Visual Accessibility and Universal Design

Editors must advocate for all users, including those using assistive technologies or navigating documents with visual impairments.

  • Alternative Text (Alt Text): Ensure every image and figure in digital documents contains concise, meaningful alt text. Alt text should describe the key insight or content of the image for screen reader users, rather than simply stating “Chart” or “Image.”
  • Color Contrast: Verify that text embedded in graphics meets Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) contrast ratios (at least 4.5:1 for standard body text).
  • Colorblind-Friendly Palettes: Never rely solely on color to convey information (e.g., red bars for “fail” and green bars for “pass”). Use distinct patterns, high contrast, or direct test labels alongside color coding so the chart remains readable in grayscale or for colorblind readers.

Practical Editorial Revisions for Visuals and Tables

The following table summarizes common visual design and tabular flaws, along with recommended editorial actions and corrected layout strategies:

Table 11.1
Editorial Revisions for Common Visual and Tabular Flaws
Design Flaw Editor’s Diagnosis & Action Corrected Layout Strategy
Unreferenced Visual A figure or table appears on the page without any prior mention or callout in the body text. Insert an explicit in-text reference (e.g., “See Figure 11.2”) prior to the graphic, explaining its relevance.
Truncated Y-Axis A bar chart’s baseline starts at a non-zero value, visual distortion exaggerating minor differences. Reset the Y-axis scale to zero or use a broken axis break symbol if a non-zero start is strictly necessary and explicitly noted.
Mismatched Alignment Numerical data in a table is left-aligned or centered, making decimal comparisons difficult. Right-align or decimal align numerical data columns; left-align row labels and text cells.
Inconsistent Units Column headers lack unit designations, forcing units (e.g., lbs, kg, $) to repeat in every data cell. Move units of measurement directly into the column header parenthetically and remove redundant symbols from data cells.
Color-Dependent Data A line chart uses only color (e.g., red line vs. green line) to differentiate data series. Add varying line styles (e.g., solid vs. dashed lines) or distinct geometric markers (circles, squares) to each data line.
Orphaned Visual Captions A figure caption appears at the bottom of a page while the graphic reflows to the next page. Set paragraph formatting to “keep with next” to lock the visual element and its corresponding caption/title together on the same page.

Working with Authors and Designers on Visual Elements

Editing graphics and tables requires diplomacy, clear communication, and collaborative problem-solving. Authors often invest considerable effort into creating custom charts, and graphic design teams operate under strict layout budgets and technical tools.

Communicating Visual Edits to Authors

When flagging a flawed visual or table, avoid vague feedback like “This chart looks confusing.” Instead, ground your queries in usability, readability, and audience needs:

  • Focus on Functional Rationale: Explain why a change is necessary. For example: “I recommend converting paragraphs 4–6 into a summary table. This will allow executives to quickly compare project costs across all three phases without reading through dense prose.”
  • Provide Specific Solutions: If a chart is poorly designed, offer a rough sketch, a mock-up, or a clear structural outline of how the table should be reformatted.
  • Query Missing Sources: If a graphic lacks source notes, vector source files, or high-resolution assets, leave a polite author query: “Author: Please provide the high-resolution source file (.eps or .png) for Figure 3 to ensure text legibility in print, and confirm the original data source for the caption footnote.”

Partnering with Design Teams

In modern professional publishing, editors frequently work alongside graphic designers and production staff. Early communication prevents costly redesigns late in the production workflow. Supply designers with clean, standardized table data (e.g., formatted in a spreadsheet or styled document) and precise instructions regarding heading hierarchy, figure placement, and accessibility requirements.

Knowledge Check


  1. Tufte, E.R. (1983). The Visual Display of Quantitative Information. Graphics Press. ↵